Film School: Neighbors

He's had some duds in the past few years, but Seth Rogen is officially a bankable comedy star. He's not putting up Ferrell and Sandler box office numbers, but he's gotten to the point where his production company releases a movie every summer. He's reliable enough for laughs that even with members of the Apatow family as co-stars in some of his most recent work, he's still the main attraction for most moviegoers. There is just too much wrong with Neighbors for Rogen to save the day this time around.

From the jump, I was confused with the Zac Efron casting. There's no obvious alternative, and that's probably how he got the job, but is he even famous really? The premise of the movie is not that a fraternity moves in next door. It's that the married couple played by Rogen and Rose Byrne don't want to come to terms with the boring lifestyle their newborn daughter has brought. They want to be cool again — if you didn't get this, they literally repeat it four times in the first half hour — and oh by the way, a fraternity moves in next door.

The movie is all jokes. This isn't a bad thing. Good comedies aren't necessarily heartwarming films. It's just that so many of them fall flat in the same way all the "by the hymen of Olivia Newton-John" type jokes did in Anchorman 2. Some of them probably could have been. Hannibal Buress and Jerrod Carmichael are very funny guys, and they weren't used properly. There's a scene where Efron and Dave Franco's characters go back and forth in this non-sense one-up battle. Franco pulls it off. Efron doesn't. If you're directing this (I assume) big budget comedy, shouldn't you realize this?

It's hard to tell when they gave up on the movie. Is it when they decided to throw 10 cameos in the first act? Or was it in the editing room because there are some weird cuts in this movie.

If there's a bright spot, it's that Rogen, the actor, isn't washed up. He's the movie's highlight. He's fat, loveable and knows how to deliver jokes. We saw that in Knocked Up, and we still saw that in This Is The End. Rogen, the idea man and producer and Hollywood big shot and hopeful starmaker, may need to step back and re-evaluate the results from his recent work.